Can YOU Detect an AI Voice?

Can YOU Detect an AI Voice?

Dave's Garage

5 месяцев назад

23,776 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@Win11frank
@Win11frank - 08.02.2025 21:38

Sound good as hell

Ответить
@user-kn8wi2xt6f
@user-kn8wi2xt6f - 08.02.2025 22:34

Sounds completely authentic

Ответить
@mobayguy
@mobayguy - 09.02.2025 02:12

Had I not been asked to judge nor saw the effect, I'd not have detected any variance. Prompted, the variance is very minute indeed. The word "shop" is overemphasized and ".com" is a bit extended. Completely believeable overall.

Ответить
@vincep1c156
@vincep1c156 - 09.02.2025 17:44

Preface… I know it’s AI generated so my conclusion is biased.
Sounds very close, to me the rate and pauses seem off. Also it definitely doesn’t sound like your normal microphone, it’s a bit thin and has more compression on the ai voice. But hey what do I know… it’s still very very good. I use ElevenLabs to read long documents and books, to me it’s the best out there…

Ответить
@UnboxedGarage
@UnboxedGarage - 10.02.2025 19:24

sounds great, although it doesn't have the "human" tonal inflections - that being said if you didn't let us know I'd say 99.9% of all of us would have just listened and thought it was you.

Ответить
@anpn33
@anpn33 - 13.02.2025 08:37

Very close, but sounds like you have a cold.

Ответить
@jessegador
@jessegador - 14.02.2025 20:58

Wow we could not differentiate it.😮

Ответить
@desperatefortuneproduction3296
@desperatefortuneproduction3296 - 14.02.2025 21:05

I just ran one of your videos after listening to the AI. It sounds very similar but I thought the AI version is in a very slightly higher register. I think your real life deeper tones aren't found in this AI version.

Ответить
@QEngineering
@QEngineering - 14.02.2025 21:29

The voice sounds right, but the inflection is off. If you were one of my in life friends I'd be heading for your place with a 6 pack thinking something is wrong because it feels like a sad version of your speech.

Ответить
@gracemember101
@gracemember101 - 14.02.2025 21:42

I would not be able to tell. Scary.

Ответить
@richardjohnson8731
@richardjohnson8731 - 14.02.2025 22:49

It sounds a bit off but I only concluded that after 'you' owned up.

Ответить
@Sam_Saraguy
@Sam_Saraguy - 14.02.2025 22:49

Sounds very natural to my ears, and sounds just like you.

Ответить
@Yooakim
@Yooakim - 14.02.2025 23:16

Scary

Ответить
@darrengeorge9965
@darrengeorge9965 - 14.02.2025 23:57

It articulated "Hey I'm Dave" with a different inflection and excessive diction as to how you normally would present the phrase

Ответить
@williamsteele
@williamsteele - 15.02.2025 00:00

Having listened to you for decades, it's easy to spot that it's an AI fake... however, it's damn close... there are only a few points where the AIness shows through... but it's actually really good.

Ответить
@timothywandell728
@timothywandell728 - 15.02.2025 00:03

Frighteningly close.

Ответить
@mikeperry2814
@mikeperry2814 - 15.02.2025 05:27

Sounds 95% accurate, except 10-15% fast. WOW!

Ответить
@RB-cz5jn
@RB-cz5jn - 15.02.2025 12:14

👍
Was Deepseek leaked maybe the Asian motherships detailed good citizen model..
Just conspiracy

Ответить
@mrwarr
@mrwarr - 15.02.2025 18:48

Different enough to make me wonder what changed in your signal chain. Similar enough that I would have never thought it was AI. Wild.

Ответить
@AndyRoche
@AndyRoche - 15.02.2025 20:20

I would have to say that at a quick listen it might pass. It sounds like you but my gut keeps telling me something that there are certain phrases and pronunciations that are just a bit "off".

Ответить
@SwissPGO
@SwissPGO - 15.02.2025 23:54

Lipsync is not good but I'm very sensitive to this and that's why I hate dubbed movies so much.
The voice itself is scary good. Scary times now that one can no longer have confidence in any video or radio transmission with a person you know well. Secret codewords and answers options in some situations, but AI is a societal big bang event

Ответить
@ockertwessels649
@ockertwessels649 - 16.02.2025 00:52

To be honest, yes, listening carefully one can hear that it is not the normal voice played through the usual equipment. I'd be hard pressed to say if it were an artificial voice, or a normal voice altered in some way. N's D's and O's sound most artificial. Long A's ("Dave") also. Note- listening to it a second time, it was already more difficult to identify it as generated. Habituation seems to happen very quickly.

Ответить
@jonbjorkeback9499
@jonbjorkeback9499 - 16.02.2025 04:01

Soundwise it is uncanningly close, the delivery is different though. If I werent paying attention I could've been fooled.

Ответить
@JohnCorrUK
@JohnCorrUK - 16.02.2025 12:51

Very very real Dave

Ответить
@JonRowlison
@JonRowlison - 16.02.2025 21:40

In general it sounds pretty good - BUT - I think some of your natural dips into you lower voice range got skipped (general tone is higher than you generally present.) If there were more drops, which it does more of toward the end, it would be much more difficult to spot.

Ответить
@stevencrawford6503
@stevencrawford6503 - 18.02.2025 10:36

I can tell something is off, but I don't think I would notice if you didn't say anything.

Slightly less personality in it, but hella accurate

Ответить
@Ethereial
@Ethereial - 19.02.2025 00:48

Wow, that is impressive!

Ответить
@ignatzmuskrat3000
@ignatzmuskrat3000 - 19.02.2025 00:52

Been hearing too many ads for medicaid using the wrong voice for the face. It's like hearing auto-tune.

Ответить
@BaumInventions
@BaumInventions - 19.02.2025 03:01

Holy smokes... Thats insanely good.

Ответить
@carpecanem611
@carpecanem611 - 19.02.2025 05:36

I'm tempted to do a comparison of the real voice vs AI using something like Audacity. But the AI sounds very believable.

Ответить
@dombo813
@dombo813 - 19.02.2025 10:48

Computer generated voice is very good, the biggest tell for me is just that the script is always a bit robotic, the generator doesn't quite get the pauses or vocal tics right.

Ответить
@NorbertdeRooy
@NorbertdeRooy - 21.02.2025 16:31

It definitively sounds off, but not enough that if you didn't mention it I would have noticed.

Now the kicker would ofc be that you lied and this is actually not AI generated but just a social experiment.

Ответить
@randospawn7495
@randospawn7495 - 22.02.2025 00:53

Kinda but listen closely, it uses the ai like tones that that don't sound natural when you robotically don't shift tone at all while talking

Ответить
@AnthonyLoPrimo
@AnthonyLoPrimo - 06.03.2025 14:16

It's very subtly off. Very close, and if I wasn't specifically listening to it I would probably not have realized it for the first few minutes.

Ответить
@SELECT289
@SELECT289 - 06.03.2025 15:17

very close approximation, but even if i didn't know it was AI I might wonder if it was recorded improperly or put through a filter for no reason.

Ответить
@mikefarrington7141
@mikefarrington7141 - 06.03.2025 17:25

That is excellent with your speaking style and cadence and inflections. Towards the end where "you" talk about what is coming up next, it lacks an enthusiastic upspeak that I usually hear from you (is that a real word or did I just make that up?)

Ответить
@Jonathanwootton
@Jonathanwootton - 06.03.2025 21:17

frightningly good

Ответить
@MagicBoterham
@MagicBoterham - 16.03.2025 19:57

The usage of voice inflection does not match non-ai Dave.

Ответить
@WPF465B
@WPF465B - 17.03.2025 17:57

Sounds natural to me.

Ответить
@matthewwoods6972
@matthewwoods6972 - 27.03.2025 11:43

90-95% completely undetectable. Except when it tried to do your tone variation when answer a question or in this case acknowledge that the voice is ai. However I don't believe that the minor differences would be noted by anyone who wasn't legitimately looking for it.

Ответить
@Karl_Kampfwagen
@Karl_Kampfwagen - 29.03.2025 05:17

Not bad, but the tonal inflections that you put on technical terms isn't quite the same. Very listenable, but it's not quite "real." Awesome test, Dave 👍

Ответить
@BulkybearOG
@BulkybearOG - 01.04.2025 16:48

Sounds higher pitch than normal.

Ответить
@salvadorseekatzrisquez2947
@salvadorseekatzrisquez2947 - 01.04.2025 18:37

I having a member for about a month and without the real face to match. Just the audio is perfectly believable. It does sounds a bit like if you had a cold or sore throat

Ответить
@garmrdmr
@garmrdmr - 05.04.2025 03:27

i wouldnt have guessed and i DO watch quite a few of your videos

Ответить
@jetwright3066
@jetwright3066 - 06.04.2025 04:01

Dave: Keep up rhe good work....😎😎😎

Ответить
@jefferyb304
@jefferyb304 - 08.04.2025 14:46

It's a little off. If it were a phone call or played on a cheap sound system, I might be fooled.

Ответить
@YoutubeBorkedMyOldHandle_why
@YoutubeBorkedMyOldHandle_why - 08.04.2025 20:45

Pretty scary and concerning. Personally, knowing that it's fake, I'd say it sounds just slightly off. The real giveaway that speech was AI generated however, isn't usually the tone, rather it is the simple mistakes such as: errors in pronunciation of simple words or phrases, or pauses which occur in the wrong place ... mistakes which a native speaker would never make, especially when the speech seems nearly perfect otherwise.

Ответить
@peterh222
@peterh222 - 14.04.2025 08:53

This voice is so authentic and believable I have already sent it $500 in Best Buy gift certificates

Ответить
@diddykong9366
@diddykong9366 - 19.04.2025 08:53

its the lack of different hz. it sounds like one steady hz level. no breaks just constant steady flow.

Ответить
@gengarvenom1180
@gengarvenom1180 - 20.04.2025 09:03

Its incredibly obvious. Sometimes I have to sit there and think about it, but rhis isnt one of those times.

Ответить