Barstool Pizza Review - Johnny's New York Style Pizza (West Point, GA)

Either heat it up or don't. Reheated not in the oven long enough is the worst.

Stuffing that score full of helium gas, everybody knows the rules.

an undercooked doughy floppy 5.8 is mysteriously a 7.1??

Even if he just crossed the street Pres will never know what town he's in. Everybody knows the rules.

always get the slice well done.

get the whole pie. well done. Zero flop.

Hella Pie, in Tracy CA 🔥

DAVE BACK IN GA!!

Looked like a 5 to me

The undercarriage was white!!! What are we even doing now Dave???

7.1?????????? More like a 5.1

🤮

0.3

Alright pizza review town

New York Style is tough to top.

2 minute review, everyone know it was a 6.1

This pizza looked like wet skin, he basically had to drink it, and the undercarriage completely pale. 5.2

All day 6.8. Glad to see you getting soft in your old age.

Dave is so soft now. Johnny’s is at best a 6.3.

Looks like a garbage slice. He gave it a high score for some reason.

I didn't expect a good score when I seen it was 2 minutes. 7.1 was probably generous

When the review is 2 minutes you know it’s gonna be a generous score

Mr Pizza Pizza 🍕tee 5.6

i dont know pizza like dave but man that looked in the 6s at least

That’s a 2:30 am pizza nothing else

Spoiler blocker

🍕😋

Super floppy terrible pizza.. 7.1. Dave is such a softy now lol.

Looked like a 61

Using a carton for 1 slice is a crime

Seriously Dave?
Ohh f0ck...c'mon!!!
This slice shoud be scored at maximum: 5.1 and nothing more‼‼

After these 8 beers I'm grabbing my keys and speeding down to Pizza Review Town

Dave has gone soft. Easy 5.4 all day long

Cooker! Sir! Hope you are doing well. Crazy to see you on a pizza video. KING OF BATTLE!

@onebite the pizza prince, canton Ga

Spoiler Blocker

One pizza review town, everybody knows the rules.

Soft.

It looked awful

There’s no way it’s getting above a 5

I work in West Point, I couldn’t imagine running into Dave 🤣

A 1 bite score for real!!! Mind blown! 😂

If you ever come back to this part of the country you have to hit up Cerrone's in Columbus GA. Guarantee at least an 8.2!

"Not a bad looking slice " - The guy we get pizza reviews from.

Come try abo's in Broomfield Colorado

"West Point, Pizza review town!" - Dave Portnoy

Another sympathy juiced 7.1
This is getting old now

6.7 on a good day. 7.1 was him being super generous . On a real dave scale thats a 6.1

When you get a chance please try baci pizza in montrose by - upper westchester. The pizza is amazing. You won’t be disappointed. Definitely above 9.0

I hope Dave hasn't sold out because I've eaten at Johnny's and it's not the best in the biz