Комментарии:
With all Hilleberg tents you should always choose the next size that you would otherwise need, so for 2 people a 3 person tent is better.
ОтветитьHi, love your vids. What is windy conditions like when you are hiking the mountains in Tasmania?
ОтветитьI bought a decathalon 2 person tent for solo winter. ❤
ОтветитьShould i carry a 2 person if im solo?
ОтветитьCan you make a video about more tents that you have ? I had the msr hubba hubba nx and through high winds in scotland the rainfly ripped open from top to bottom so now I'm looking for a windproof tent and people all say take hilleberg, don't now how strong the msr snowtent is.
ОтветитьAccess 2 if your taller than 5ft forget it lol
ОтветитьAnother good video Mowser. Hats off to you for making the video. You could have chosen not to advertise your ‘mistake’. Like you said openly the Hilleberg is a very sturdy brand tent for severe conditions and it didn’t suit you as you are big, (I am 6’2”) which makes life in a tent more difficult and furthermore you clearly intended to use it as a full three person tent. Personally, I find that tapered or asymmetrical tents are always more difficult (ie. ‘’Painful’) and in some particular way in some aspect of design and compromised usage compared to their non-tapered cousins. When I see them on the plan I am put off straight away. Additionally you have been honest and given yourself some self-criticism about ‘not doing enough research’. This is my take on the theme of the video, as distinct from criticism of the product or brand (with the exception of the issue with vestibule tensioning), which has unintentionally cause some offense to some of the Hilleberg loyal customers. It is my experience that if something personally ‘niggles’ you about a bit of gear then it will always annoy you unless it can be fixed or you get rid of it znd replace it with something that you are content with. Hilleberg tents break too. Under severe conditions their poles can and do sometimes break. That has been well documented since their existence. Probably after most tents have been blown off the mountainside. An important aspect of marketing is earning a reputation of brand loyalty and I believe that Hilleberg has gained this, although it doesn’t mean that it is the only high quality brand of tent on the market.
ОтветитьGood video but you need to do longer takes. The jumping around is a bit distracting. Most of your comments are not problems with the tent but just that it wasn’t what you wanted size wise.
ОтветитьCheck out Barentsoutdoors and Nortent
ОтветитьHave over 100 nights in Hilleberg Allak 2 - perfect for kayak hiking, little heavy for long hikes, but solid, vel built tent. Used it for a four week car trip in Noway (Lofoten, Andøya) with two persons and a dog, no problem 😊
ОтветитьThis video is not about a tent, this video is about the fact that you do not fit in 160 cm. This is strange.
Ответитьbut if you now that the tent is less than 70 in wide why would you try to fit 3 25in pads and then complain?
ОтветитьHow do you pitch the MSR access in heavy rain as a whole? Or use the tent as shelter without inner tent? I think you cant, right? This both makes the Hilleberg VERY different and advanced and therefore difficult to compare this two typ of tents, right? The Hilleberg you can pitch in bad weather condition, while everything will get pretty wet once you try to pitch the MSR inner tent first before adding the outer tent when its raining...
ОтветитьAccomplished and interesting vid. 👍
ОтветитьTo be fair, these two tents cannot be compared as they are completely different products. The access is a good tent, but the materials are much lighter (and thus they can take less of a beating), it’s an inner tent first setup (making it pretty much useless in very wet climates) and the pole structure is much more flimsy compared to the Allak. Yes, the Access is much lighter but it comes at a cost.
ОтветитьDo you know what's good for Hilleberg Allak 3?? Pygmy size people, maybe Asians or other races of pygmies coming from all different corners of the globe! 🤣
ОтветитьEvery MSR test ive owned has wetted out / leaked! I do not trust that brand anymore. :( Hilleberg and Fjällräven make the best tents imho!
ОтветитьNallo 4 brother
ОтветитьTent dimensions are an issue for the 6 feet and limit options considerably unless you want to brush up on the sides of the walls.
That said some companies are getting on board with the 25-inch pads and making the bases that bigger to accommodate.
Classic you upsize what you want to fit with a tent size +1 of the number of people you want to bring, eg you get a 4-man tent next time.
My goto has been Kathmandu’s Northstar XT, got it for a steal at $150, RRP800?(simalier to the Macpac Olympus), a 2 man 4season has 6 guys lines+4 additional... but don't use them, with gear inside I only use 4 for the outer fly vestibules, a little more weight but the solid tent in any condition. Yep, 3.5kg but never had an issue in the 10ish years camping. still looks brand new.
Who doesn’t already know that you always subtract one person from the claimed amount? You should know that as an experienced person. I have the Allak 3 as a roomy one person tent. At most it’s a 2 person. If you want a 3 man tent, buy a four man tent at least.
ОтветитьI have rarely found a tent size quoted as being nothing more than a guideline from the manufacturer. When I took my kids I bought a 3 man Coleman, cant remember which one, because in the showroom I stuffed my kids in to check the room, Husky also. Only tent that had the room but paid the price with the weight.
I solo camp nowadays but use a so called 2 man for myself. I have a number of these, Hoolie 2, Terra Nova Voyager are roomy and have seen all UK storms in these. I do have smaller one man tents, Hilleberg solo (bring ear plugs), a great little one man Robens, and a Nemo1P ( 2 season, 3 at a push} I tend to use the single tents when bike packing. I also haver a Rab ridge raider for the odd night but tend to use it as an all season bivvy bag, (not for the claustrophobic). I am hoping my kids, now all adults, will buy their own tents, but if have to share will apply the "add 1" principle to the sizing.
“70 inch across”? Yet you want to fit 3 x 25 inch wide pads? Math much?
ОтветитьThinking about upgrading to allak 2for myself, something i dont have to worry about ik a windy winter camp
ОтветитьNice vid mate...
IMHO Hilleberg makes the BEST tents on the planet and I've used a lot. I would say for me Fjällräven is 2nd and other brands I like are TNF, Mountain Hardware, Eureka, Nordisk, Terra Nova. Samaya, Others are just ok like Black Diamond, Nemo, BA, and MSR.
I have NEVER owned an MSR tent that didn't leak. Moved too much in bad winds. I have a Staika (BL) and it's the top three tents I own. If you can afford it and can split the weight, the Keron or Nammaj 3 are both BL and super strong (not freestanding tho).
Just my thoughts.... I would always by a Staika over the Allak (although has better ventilation).
I can verify as an owner of both Allak2 and 3 that the latter is rather a large two person tent especially in wintertime with loads of gear and thick sleeping bags, frozen condesation on the walls and ceiling etc. You may fit in three adults with regular width pads but I would not take my largest friends with me because I appreciate some space and possibility to more or less live in the tent in case of many days bad weather. A fast trip with no intention to spend much time in the tent and regular sized mates who know how to keep their stuff and gadgets well organized, then Allak 3 might be spaciuous enough for three. The weight difference between 2 and 3 is so small I would prefer the bigger one in most cases.
ОтветитьDo NOT buy the msr - wind over 12 m/s it bends like crazy and will smack you In the head ( the poles) the fly is not Connected to the poles and they will bend In to your face . It was the worst tent I ever used- expensive and bad. Day 2 the cyclone poles splintered 😢
ОтветитьHi Mowser, wow - funny that. I made almost an exactly the same video as this. I actually traded my Allak 2 to a guy in Tasmania (for his Nammatj 2). I actually got a fair amount of backlash from people disagreeing with me that the Allak was too flimsy for high winds (but they're all wrong). lol.
ОтветитьEverytime when i pitch my Allak 2 I'm so happy. I like the look, I like the feel, I like the space I like everything but the weight. But it manageable after all.
ОтветитьTLDR; Man discovers that 75" > 67" and 8lbs 3oz is a bit heavy
ОтветитьJust a few thoughts:
Hilleberg will sometimes produce a tent with faulty tension on the fabric, especially common around 2020 production. It’s not all tents, yours was simply faulty.
The Allak is a great tent but its definitely not one of the strongest from Hilleberg, especially the 3 as it’s bigger.
I’ve used my Keron tents on Greenland expedition and those are the best tents in high winds that don’t change direction and on snow.
The MSR is not very strong, despite the marketing. My buddy Tom Heanley has great videos on that. You can check it out and know what it can handle.
Cheers
Sounds to me like you are complaining about nothing 🤷🏻♂️!
Your biggest complaints are about the internal size and weight, yet you had all the specifications in the Hilleberg brochure and you still went ahead and bought the tent fully aware of this,…well that’s your mistake I’m afraid, you can’t really complain about it after the event because you made the wrong decision despite having all the relevant information.
If you’re unsure about the internal dimensions of the tent, the best way to assess this is by using a roll of insulating tape and actually taping out the internal dimensions of the tent on your living room floor, then you can physically put down your sleeping mats in this area and make a judgement if the area provided will be big enough for you.
Regarding the looseness of the fly sheet around the door area, at he base of the tent there is a webbing tape about 20mm wide from memory that joins the open sides at the door, this can be increased or decreased in length to get the correct tension on the door panel and zip, get this too long and the fly sheet door section will be loose and flap, if it’s too short this will put too much tension on the door zip, at best you won’t be able to close the zip easily, worst case scenario means you could break the zip.
Did you try adjusting this webbing for correct tension??
People also get hung up about the weight of a tent and forget that the main consideration is total backpack weight, that’s what you have to carry, not just the tent, I’ve got the Allak 2 and I’m aware that I could easily get a tent at least a kilo lighter, but for me camping solo in this, it’s like a palace 😬 ….some people complain about the weight of Hilleberg tents but seem to forget about the six cans of beer they are also carrying 😂😂 I don’t take anything like that, my priority is in a decent strong tent that won’t let me down.
There was actually nothing wrong with your Hilleberg tent ⛺️, just a case of operator error from what I can see 🤷🏻♂️?
Thanks for the input.i,m now looking at the fjallraven abisko dome 3.more room plus 2 lower side vents which if my girls are with me should reduce condensation.cheers mate.
ОтветитьThe Hilleberg tents are bombproof. That’s why I have three of them. Too bad that you didn’t contact Hilleberg customer service about the floppy vestibules, as I’m sure they would have taken care of you. My latest purchase from Hilleberg, was a Soulo (red label). There was something not quite right with that tent, so I contacted the shop where I bought it. I received another Soulo, which was not quite right either. Then Hilleberg customer service contacted me. They took a third Soulo, checked it at their warehouse, made sure it was ok, and shipped it out to me. Because of the hassle, I was compensated with a few free Hilleberg products of my choosing. I got free snow pegs, and I also got some bungee cord for tent poles. Hilleberg tents are heavier, and more expensive than some other tents. However, if you do proper research, and are willing to carry a bit more weight, Hilleberg tents are tents you can count on. From experience, I can say that my Allak 2 can take a serious beating, and I trust my Hilleberg tents to take care of me. Of course, Hilleberg tents are made for more extreme conditions. But, that is what I’m counting on when putting up my tents in the Norwegian mountains. ATB from Norway 🇳🇴
ОтветитьThe Hilleberg and MSR are very different tents with different uses. Hilleberg is ment for scandinavian or other conditions where (a lot of) rain is expected. The MSR is a inner first tent and is more or less useless around here in Sweden and Norway as the inner will get wet before you get the fly on. It may work in snow, as the snow will fall off the inner. The MSR may very well be a better choise in dry areas.
ОтветитьToo heavy? Used to carry a Tarra up the Scottish mountains, now that was heavy but a palace in the hills. After carrying the tarra, my other tents like the nammatj 2 would feel weightless.
Ответитьthank you for this good video. I owned the msr access 2 and also the hilleberg allak 2. The Allak 2 was to small for me and my dog. The Msr Access is not a four season tent, that is my opinion for Swedish conditions not works. So now i use the Hilleberg Staika and i love this tent, but heavy 4 kg.
Maybe the Kerron 3 fit 3 persons, but heavy 4,2 kg.
JUST SUBSCRIBED !!!
Ответить